tf/swingtrading•Posted by u/swing_king•about 2 months ago•1 min read

Swing trading vs day trading — I tried both for a year and here's what I found

I spent the first 6 months of 2025 day trading and the second 6 months swing trading. Same account ($20k), same markets (US equities). Here's my honest comparison.

Day Trading (Jan-June 2025)

P/L: -$2,400 (after commissions)
Trades: ~580
Win rate: 48%
Avg winner: $145 | Avg loser: $162
Screen time: 6+ hours/day
Mental health: terrible. Constant stress, couldn't focus at work.

Swing Trading (July-Dec 2025)

P/L: +$3,100
Trades: ~65
Win rate: 52%
Avg winner: $380 | Avg loser: $195
Screen time: 30-45 min/day (evenings, scanning charts)
Mental health: dramatically better. Trades play out over days so you're not glued to every tick.

For me, swing trading is clearly the better fit. I'm not fast enough or disciplined enough for day trading. But I know it works for others. What's your experience?

4 Comments

Connectez-vous pour laisser un commentaire

Sort by:

swing_kingOP·about 2 months agoedited

This is a great comparison and mirrors my experience exactly. Swing trading lets you have a life. Day trading consumed mine for 2 years before I switched.

The key insight from your numbers: your swing trading has a much better reward:risk ratio (380:195 ≈ 2:1) vs day trading (145:162 ≈ 0.9:1). That's the real difference — swing trades give you room for the trade to work.

189

chart_wizard·about 2 months agoedited

The R:R difference makes sense structurally too. Swing trades capture multi-day moves, so your targets can be $5-10 on a stock. Day trades are fighting for $0.50-1.00. The transaction costs eat into day trading way more proportionally.

trader_mike·about 2 months agoedited

I disagree that swing trading is "better" — it's better FOR YOU. I'm the opposite: I can't hold overnight. The anxiety of overnight gaps, earnings surprises, and geopolitical events makes me a terrible swing trader. I need the clean slate of closing flat every day.

The real lesson here is that matching your trading style to your personality matters more than any strategy.

156

chart_wizard·about 2 months agoedited

Honest question: did your day trading results improve over the 6 months? Because a 48% win rate with slightly negative R:R suggests your strategy might have worked if you gave it more time and refined it. 6 months is a really short sample size for day trading.