tf/beginners•Posted by u/newbie_investor•about 2 months ago

How does trading in a car work? Dealership offered me way less than KBB value

Okay this isn't about financial markets but I figure this community understands valuations and negotiations better than anyone lol.

I have a 2022 Toyota Camry with 28,000 miles in excellent condition. KBB says trade-in value is $23,500. The dealership offered me $19,800. That's a $3,700 gap!

Is this normal? How do I negotiate a better trade-in value? Should I sell privately instead? Any car trading pros in here?

3 Comments

Connectez-vous pour laisser un commentaire

Sort by:

trader_mike·about 2 months agoedited

Wrong kind of trading my friend 😂 But I'll help anyway because I literally just did this.

Dealerships ALWAYS lowball on trade-ins. Their margin comes from the spread between what they give you and what they sell it for. Think of it like a market maker's bid-ask spread.

Tips: (1) Get quotes from CarMax, Vroom, and Carvana first — they're usually higher than dealer trade-ins and give you leverage. (2) Negotiate the trade-in SEPARATELY from the new car purchase. Dealers love to bundle them to confuse you. (3) If the gap is too big, sell privately on Facebook Marketplace. You'll get more but it's more hassle.

algo_trader_42·about 2 months agoedited

The bid-ask spread comparison is actually perfect lol. Dealerships are just market makers for cars with terrible execution.

crypto_dave·about 2 months agoedited

Sir, this is a trading forum. But honestly respect the energy. Also the real answer is never trade in — always sell private. The delta between private sale and trade-in is almost always $3,000-5,000. Yes it's annoying but that's basically free money for a few hours of work.